Login
Register
Login
Register
Communities
Directory
Help
Language
Legal
Search
Communities
Directory
Help
Language
Legal
Search
Visit
Poke
Streams
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 08:46:01 -0500
from Y
Axehaft
wrote the following
post
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 08:46:00 -0500
It is possible to join 'groups' on other instances from my Streams instance? ie. I want to join this group on Minds:
https://www.minds.com/group/1610484328913965071/latest
Can I do this from my Streams instance or do I have to sign up for a Minds account to do this?
@
Axehaft (axe@8633.pm)
Link to source
22873a89-605f-4546-8c7e-3487918b707a
Visit
Poke
Giac El Vecio
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 10:47:19 -0500
from Diversi Spiritus
You can join the groups using "streams" software (and probably others using zot protocol) and, about the others using ActivityPub for example, you need to do some tests...
Link to source
1 Like
Axehaft (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Bill Statler
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 11:04:36 -0500
from Bunny of Doom
I got curious, and found this:
https://developers.minds.com/docs/decentralization/activitypub
Not a lot of information there. Seems like there isn't any technical obstacle to joining a group from a streams-based instance, but it depends on how Minds allows you to join a group at their end. (I haven't tried it.)
Link to source
2 Likes
Giac El Vecio (2 months ago)
Axehaft (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Axehaft
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 11:54:57 -0500
from Axehaft Streams
Ya. I think 'how Minds allows you to join a group' is the issue. When you click join group they take you to a Minds login/register rather than allowing me to use my streams address.
Link to source
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Bill Statler
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 12:19:56 -0500
from Bunny of Doom
You could try an experiment from your end and see what happens. Go to your Connections page, and put the group's URL (minus the "latest") into the Add New Connection box.
If we don't hear back from you, we'll know this made your instance catch on fire.
Link to source
2 Likes
Axehaft (2 months ago)
Langdon Alger (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Axehaft
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 13:35:59 -0500
from Axehaft Streams
Didn't work. I was super hopeful though. 😅 Thanks for the suggestion.
Link to source
IMG_20240312_133325.jpg
Visit
Poke
Mike Macgirvin 🖥️
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 14:26:17 -0500
from Y
If the Minds group presents as a 'Group' actor type, connecting to it from streams sends both a 'Follow' and 'Join' activity, since not everybody implements the spec the same way. This should connect you. But the deal is that nobody can agree on how to post an initial topic to a group. We support a number of different ways, but some projects (Lemmy for instance) require you to post if from a Lemmy account.
I'm just telling you what I know. Haven't looked at all into minds federation.
The joy of ActivityPub where every project interprets the spec completely different and one needs to tweak their code to federate cleanly with each and every one.
Link to source
3 Likes
Bill Statler (2 months ago)
Axehaft (2 months ago)
RainbowLink Inc. ( 株式会社レインボーリンク ) (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Axehaft
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 15:10:54 -0500
from Axehaft Streams
Again. Good info. Learning lots here! The Fediverse does seem a bit like the wild wild west at this point. lol. Fun to learn though. Thanks!
Link to source
2 Likes
Giac El Vecio (2 months ago)
RainbowLink Inc. ( 株式会社レインボーリンク ) (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Visit
Poke
Streams
Tue, 12 Mar 2024 16:24:52 -0500
from Y
It seems that Minds groups don't federate yet. From their documentation only Person types are currently supported and my poking around confirms that the documentation is probably accurate.
Link to source
3 Likes
Bill Statler (2 months ago)
Axehaft (2 months ago)
RainbowLink Inc. ( 株式会社レインボーリンク ) (2 months ago)
1 Repeat
Streams (2 months ago)
Login
Login/Email
Password
Remember me
Login
Register
Password Reset
Remote Authentication